December 10

Print Code and Citation Information Data Share

As a follow up to yesterday’s post about copyright issues with state codes, the data that I collected on print state versions can be found on this google drive spreadsheet.

I also went through all of the states’ citation rules, because I was curious about citation requirements to commercial vs. public domain works as well as requirements to use The Bluebook (a proprietary citation system) itself by states.  So that data is also in that spreadsheet.  My main takeaways from that are:

  • 11 states require use of the Bluebook (in whole or part)
  • 22 states specfically require citation to West National Reporter System cases (instead of using the cite you can find, for example, via Google Scholar.)
  • 16 states use public domain citation formats, although many also require parallel cites to West NRS cases.  Of course, anything before the change over to Public Domain will require cite to a non-vendor or media neutral source.

I want to go back through the citation rule information and see how many states have their own citation manual, because it could be inferred that those that don’t are also Bluebook by default.  Although I did see instances of “any accepted citation format” as a guide, so in theory they could use Peter Martin’s free and open Basic Legal Citation.  I also want to get an exact count of how many of the Public Domain states really do require citation to commercial cites.  Sort of kicking myself that I didn’t think to keep track when I was doing it, although with only 16 states, it should be pretty easy to accomplish.

November 5

Regulation Data – updated

I went back and rechecked my regulation data – I got sloppy on the last column “search” when doing it initially – as I said, I finished it up on the day before I left on a vacation to Central America that I’d been planning on for about a year, so I was a little distracted – but I went back through and checked it over I’m pretty sure it all good now.

 

So here’s the spreadsheet containing information on the state of state regulations.

September 21

State Case Law Data

I made it through the survey of case law published by courts/government on the web.  You can check out the public version here. As of this writing, South Carolina is missing because their website is down.  I’ll add that into this public worksheet as well as my private official copy later.

I really started to question the validity or usefulness of collecting this data about a third of the way through this.  So this was emotionally hard to get through.  Can I admit that?  Although now that I’m done I guess I’m happy I did it because it becomes obvious how uniformly bad case law publication is. So yay?

As with the codes, more in depth analysis is to come later after I tear through all of this, but you can play with the explore button on the bottom right hand side of the spreadsheet to get some graphs.  They require some data clean up to be more accurate, but you can see that PDFs and West publishing pretty much rule the day when it comes to case law.  I don’t know why I was surprised so many states use the regional reporters as their official publication, but here we are.

Now onto regulations!